Thursday, December 4, 2008

Pope Benedict on Original Sin

In his regular weekly public audience on December 3, Pope Benedict called the doctrine of Original Sin and "alternative to a vision of despair." Excerpt from the Catholic Culture piece:

"Does Original Sin exist or not, then?" the Pontiff asked rhetorically. He pointed out that St. Paul, in sketching "the basic outlines of the doctrine" in his Letter to the Romans, explains Original Sin by comparing the Fall in Eden with the redemption brought by Christ, the new Adam.

Every rational person recognizes the reality of human weakness, the Pope said. The doctrine of Original Sin goes beyond that obvious reality to address the "ontological foundation" of evil, he said. "In effect, there is a contradiction in our being. On the one hand we know we must do good, and in our inner selves this is what we desire, yet at the same time we feel an impulse to do the opposite, to follow the path of egoism, of violence."

Many people don't seem to know this, but Muslims do not believe in the doctrine of Original Sin. I'm not a theologian, so I don't know if that's why some of them believe it's okay to kill and enslave people. But it does seem that desperation and despair characterizes Islam, even the non-violent part.

2 comments:

  1. Here is what I think is the biggest difference between the Islamic and Christian view of God. Christians see themselves as *servants* of a loving and merciful God who extends grace to us even though we don't deserve it. Muslims see themselves as *slaves* to an angry, contemptuous god -- a god who can never be pleased (no matter how many legalistic hoops they jump through), who doesn't really love, and who never extends grace.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Susan, I think that's pretty close. We serve God as his children. Calling God "Father" as we do is totally blasphemous to a Muslim.

    ReplyDelete